Jeremiah 11 — When Covenant Becomes Performance Instead of Relationship

There are moments in Scripture when God’s voice does not thunder — it aches. Jeremiah 11 is one of those moments. It is not merely a chapter of judgment or discipline; it is the cry of a wounded covenant Partner. When I first read Jeremiah 11 deeply, I realized God wasn’t angry because laws were broken — He was heartbroken because relationship had been abandoned.

The Hebrew word for covenant, בְּרִית — berit, is not the equivalent of a modern contract. A contract exchanges goods and services, but a covenant exchanges selves. Contracts protect self-interest. Covenants establish belonging, identity, and intimacy. When God says, “Obey My voice, and I will be your God, and you shall be My people” (Jeremiah 11:4), that is not a legal demand — it is the language of love.

A Revival That Wasn’t Real

Jeremiah ministered during the reign of King Josiah (cf. 2 Kings 22–23), a time when the nation experienced a wave of religious reform. Idols were torn down. Temple worship was restored. It looked like revival — revival in the temple, revival in the streets, revival in the community.

But it wasn’t revival in the heart.

Judah adjusted their behavior without adjusting their affection. They returned to religious routine, not to God. It is entirely possible to reform externals without ever surrendering the heart.

Sometimes I find myself right there.

Even as I create blog posts or videos about Jesus, intending to point people toward His glory, I sometimes catch myself subtly shifting into performance. I watch numbers, views, engagement — and although I’m speaking about Christ, inwardly I begin drifting from Him. I can serve God publicly while neglecting Him privately. I can talk about surrender while avoiding surrender.

Judah’s problem is not unfamiliar to me. It is frighteningly easy to confuse spiritual activity with spiritual intimacy.

“Hear” Means “Obey”

When God says, “Hear the words of this covenant,” in Jeremiah 11:2, the Hebrew word for hear — שָׁמַע (shamaʿ) — carries a deeper meaning than simply listening. It means to hear in such a way that it produces obedience. In the Hebrew worldview:

If I do not obey, I have not truly heard.

Israel heard sermons. They listened to Scripture. They recited truth.

But they did not obey.

And then God reminds them of their origin:

“[I brought you] out of the iron furnace.”
— Jeremiah 11:4

The “iron furnace” refers to Egypt — a place of slavery and shaping. It is as if God says, “Remember where you came from. Remember Who rescued you.”

Grace always precedes obedience.

God did not say, “Obey, and I will rescue you.”
He rescued them first, then invited them into relationship.

Obedience is not a condition of belonging;
it is the expression of belonging.

When Idolatry Hides in Obedience

Then comes the crushing indictment:

“A conspiracy exists…”
— Jeremiah 11:9

The Hebrew term קֶשֶׁר (qesher) means intentional rebellion or coordinated resistance. This isn’t accidental drifting — it is deliberate disobedience.

Judah was performing worship while practicing idolatry.

They appeared obedient in public,
but cherished idols in private.

I know what that feels like.
I have had seasons where I appeared obedient on the outside, while inwardly harboring sin in my thought life. From the outside, my life looked spiritually polished — church involvement, Bible knowledge, ministry activity — but internally I was distant. Secret sin, unconfessed struggle, or misplaced identity can hide behind public obedience.

Idols today are rarely carved images. More often, they are subtle:

• Success
• Metrics
• Social approval
• Productivity
• Ministry performance

I have found myself defining “impact” by numbers, clicks, or views. But every time I do, my heart grows restless and anxious. The Spirit convicts me gently:

“Do not measure success by reach. Measure success by resemblance to Christ.”

Obedience without intimacy becomes performance.
Ministry without presence becomes machinery.

God is never after my platform.
He is after my heart.

Judgment as Mercy

One of the most sobering verses reads:

“Though they cry out to Me, I will not listen to them.”
— Jeremiah 11:11

At first, this feels harsh. But judgment in Jeremiah is not God losing patience — it is God removing what keeps His people from Him. It is mercy in severe form. Theologian Donald Gowan wrote that God’s judgment “clears a path toward restoration.”

God disciplines not to destroy relationship, but to restore relationship.

I have experienced that discipline — not as condemnation, but as gentle, persistent conviction. God has never crushed me under the weight of my failures. I am usually harder on myself than He is. He corrects with kindness, not cruelty. Scripture says His kindness leads us to repentance (Romans 2:4).

Conviction draws me near.
Condemnation pushes me away.

When Obedience Costs You Something

The most heartbreaking section of Jeremiah 11 is deeply personal:

“I was like a gentle lamb led to the slaughter.”
— Jeremiah 11:19

Jeremiah is betrayed by people from his own hometown. His devotion to God cost him his relationships — even his safety.

Obedience sometimes divides. Obedience sometimes isolates.

I have felt this in smaller but real ways. Choosing to live counter-culturally for Christ — such as not celebrating certain holidays or refusing to participate in cultural darkness — has caused discomfort or even relational distance. Other believers sometimes misunderstand those convictions. But obedience to the truth is worth the cost.

Jesus called it the narrow road (Matthew 7:14).
The narrow road does not attract crowds — it attracts His presence.

The New Covenant — From Performance to Transformation

Jeremiah 11 ends heavy, but Jeremiah’s book does not. Later, God announces the only true solution:

“I will put My law within them,
and I will write it on their hearts.”
— Jeremiah 31:33

The Old Covenant demanded obedience from the outside in.
The New Covenant produces obedience from the inside out.

Christ fulfills the covenant that Israel broke.

He obeyed perfectly where we obey partially.
He remained faithful where we waver.
He was forsaken so we could be brought near.

He does not modify behavior —
He transforms desire.

A Personal Turning

There are moments in my walk when I feel a deep longing — a longing to rest completely in God without striving, without needing to prove anything. But in the same breath, I feel an urgency to tell others about Him while there is still time. I want to see people awakened to the beauty of Jesus, not because I want a name for myself, but because I want His Name lifted up among the nations.

That longing itself is proof of grace.
Longing is evidence of belonging.

Conclusion: Covenant Was Always About Closeness

Jeremiah 11 is not a chapter of anger — it is a chapter of invitation.

God is not asking for perfect obedience.
He is asking for presence.

He is not after productivity.
He is after proximity.

He does not say, “Work harder.”
He says:

Return to Me.

Return from performance.
Return from results-driven faith.
Return from the pressure to produce.

Return to the One who rescued you from the iron furnace.

“I will be your God.
You shall be My people.”
— Jeremiah 11:4

Not because I earned Him.
But because He chose me.

---

Closing Prayer

Lord, remove every idol that draws my heart away from You — even the ones that look like ministry. Write Your law on my heart. Make intimacy my goal, not impact. Teach me that I don’t have to perform to be loved. I want to obey not to be accepted, but because I already am.

Amen.